Tragedy in Marshall County: Fatal Amish Buggy Crash ![A Horse Drawn Buggy In Bremen Indiana]()
We have seen firsthand the heartbreak that follows preventable tragedies — but few cases are as gut-wrenching as the recent Amish buggy accident that took place on April 9, 2025, near Bremen, Indiana. A 2016 Mercedes-Benz GLA, reportedly driven by a 17-year-old, collided with a horse-drawn cart carrying three young siblings: Glenda Jo Yoder (13), Darrell Yoder (10), and Devon Yoder (9). All three children were ejected and pronounced dead at the scene.
This case is a devastating reminder of just how vulnerable horse-drawn buggies are when sharing the road with modern vehicles. These carriages offer no protection—no airbags, seat belts, or crumple zones. Even a seemingly minor collision can become deadly. Our Indianapolis car accident attorney team represents injury victims across Indiana. We’ve seen that buggies, while traditional and legally allowed, often bear the brunt of unsafe or distracted driving by those unfamiliar with how to share the road safely.
Our Car Accident Lawyers Advocate For Basic Safety Measures
One issue that cannot be overlooked is the lack of regulation surrounding buggy operators. Indiana law currently does not specify a minimum age for operating a horse-drawn vehicle. This legal gray area becomes especially troubling when you consider how often Amish children are behind the reins. While we respect and support the preservation of cultural and religious traditions, we also believe in advocating for commonsense safety measures that can save lives —
especially when children are involved.
At Keller & Keller, we’ve been fighting for the rights of families affected by tragic and often avoidable accidents for over 85 years. Our legal team is deeply familiar with the complexities of cases involving non-traditional vehicles like buggies, and we’re committed to seeking accountability and driving change that protects all Indiana families — regardless of how they travel.
Our Compassionate Personal Injury Lawyer Team Will Stand By You
Our very own Dan Armstrong spoke with WNDU about the incident to shed light on the story from a legal perspective which can be found here.
If your family has been impacted by a similar incident, we invite you to contact our office for a free, no-obligation consultation. We will listen to your story, explain your rights, and stand beside you every step of the way.
We’re here for you — because it’s more than a case. It’s your life.
